Michelle McCoy Wants Capable Women to Stop Calling Exhaustion Normal

Michelle McCoy’s work begins with a sentence she has heard many women repeat: “Everything looks normal.” The labs come back in range. The schedule keeps moving. And the woman living it knows she does not feel normal at all.

McCoy, the founder of Treasured Wellness, has a name for that stage: High-Functioning Fatigue™. She describes it as the stage before burnout, when a woman is still leading and delivering while her body has been signaling for years that something isn’t right.

Where did Michelle McCoy’s work begin?

Twenty-two years ago, McCoy sat shaking in her car with her 8-year-old daughter. Her daughter had suffered severe migraines for three years, and a neurologist had just said nothing was wrong and nothing more could be done.

Through those three years, McCoy’s gut told her the problem was connected to food. She remembers her daughter’s doctors telling her, “Food has nothing to do with her migraines. Feed her whatever she wants.” So she kept asking questions, researching and tracking her daughter’s health data. When she finally found someone who would listen, she learned her instinct had been right: food had everything to do with why her daughter was so sick.

That experience changed how she looked at the food she fed her whole family. It also gave her the habit that still anchors her work: paying close attention to patterns and writing them down.

What was her own turning point?

Her second wake-up call came years later, and it was her own. In her 30s she nearly fell asleep at the wheel at 2 in the afternoon, and she kept pushing through. A decade later she nearly passed out at her stove while making dinner.

“My body had been warning me for years, and I kept pushing through,” she writes. That night, she says, God made her lie down. She calls it her own Psalm 23 moment, and this time she was ready to listen.

The lesson shapes how she talks to clients today: “Pushing through is not leadership. It’s depletion with a noble title.” She also draws a line between stopping and restoring. In her view, the body needs to feel safe in order to recover, and restoration is fundamental to that.

What is High-Functioning Fatigue?

McCoy uses the term to describe women who look fine from the outside. They are business owners, executives and ministry leaders, the problem-solvers everyone counts on. They hit a wall at 2 p.m. and reach for a third coffee and a piece of chocolate to get through the afternoon. Their labs land in “normal” ranges, yet they know they don’t feel like themselves.

Because they are still performing, McCoy says, no one sees it, and often neither do they. What they fear losing is not only their energy but their sharp, capable mind, the one that built the life they love.

Her goal is for High-Functioning Fatigue™ to be recognized as a real stage in a woman’s life with real signals, “not simply the price of being capable, older and busy.” Her short version: functioning is not the same thing as being well.

How does she help women find answers?

McCoy helps women look at their labs, history and everyday patterns with what she calls root-cause curiosity, grounded in biblical health stewardship for the whole person: body, mind and spirit. “Your body is not a problem to manage,” she writes. “It is a temple to steward.”

Her tools grew out of those 22 years of tracking. The Treasured Wellness Journal helps a woman turn what she notices each day into a clearer understanding of what her body is asking for. She is also building OWN Your Health™, a movement around biblical health stewardship that reaches women through the journal, speaking, writing, personalized guidance and her podcast.

She shares two client stories. One CEO went from needing weekend naps to recover from her work week to being fully present with her family with steadier energy. Another woman, with her doctor’s support, came off a long-term medication and still reports sustained energy and mental clarity four years later. McCoy says the bigger win is that this client now understands what her own body needs.

McCoy has also been profiled by Voyage Minnesota.

Frequently asked questions